| 2011 Toledo Metro Player of the Year Scratch Division through White Pines | |
| Name | Total Points |
| Gerken, Brian | 1231 |
| Tyson, Terry | 1032 |
| Martin, Lynn | 741 |
| Godzak, Jeff | 688 |
| Yeager, Thomas | 643 |
| Simmons, Brian | 622 |
| Kennedy, Michael | 497 |
| Reams, Tony | 429 |
| Mullett, Jay | 310 |
| Dudek, Frank | 292 |
| Mikolajczak, David | 254 |
| Abke, Jeff | 247 |
| Moser, Theodore | 129 |
| Conrad, Scott | 118 |
| Ernst, Bill | 87 |
| McCloskey, Dan | 80 |
| Raitz, John | 74 |
| Augustyniak, Mark | 70 |
| Borer, Matt | 63 |
| Jacob, Jim | 63 |
| Mann, Fred | 59 |
| Kontak, Mark | 56 |
| Zitkovic, Duane | 50 |
| Kennedy, Jim | 37 |
| Meadows, Jeff | 36 |
| Harloff, Dave | 35 |
| Govito, Michael | 30 |
| Schreiber, Clint | 25 |
| O'Neal, Jim | 24 |
| Kontak, Mitchell | 23 |
| Gust, Douglas | 15 |
| Myers, Joshua | 15 |
| Decker, Mark | 13 |
| Aldrich, Gareth | 13 |
| Yarad, Tony | 6 |
| Holmes, Jason | 5 |
| Parks, Steve | 3 |
| Hall, Jeff | 3 |
| Morris, George | 2 |