| 2005 Player of the Year - Scratch | |
| Name | Total Points |
| Yeager, Thomas | 1153 |
| Zitkovic, John | 1047 |
| Godzak, Jeff | 921 |
| Winckowski, Scott | 882 |
| Mullett, Jay | 754 |
| Tyson, Terry | 716 |
| Augustyniak, Mark | 550 |
| Bartschy, Jason | 313 |
| Condon, Timothy | 257 |
| Joiner, Gary | 223 |
| Mikolajczak, David | 198 |
| O'Neal, Jim | 187 |
| Schreiber, Clint | 163 |
| McGill, David | 155 |
| Coolidge, Dave | 155 |
| Govito, Michael | 135 |
| Fanning, Brad | 113 |
| Brossia, Kyle | 105 |
| Ernst, Bill | 105 |
| Konczal, Greg | 93 |
| Reams, Tony | 90 |
| McCloskey, Dan | 83 |
| Wolf, Thomas | 81 |
| Pickerel, Craig | 70 |
| Kennelly, Tim | 70 |
| Zitkovic, Duane | 61 |
| Klein, John | 55 |
| McMahon, Thomas | 50 |
| Rajner, R.J. | 50 |
| Kontak, Tim | 44 |
| Nieckarz, Ken | 40 |
| Salsbury, Wes | 30 |
| Curry, Tom | 23 |
| Donner, Scott | 21 |
| Carroll, John | 18 |
| Wilson, Mike | 13 |
| Warner, Steve | 13 |
| McCarthy, Mike | 13 |
| Bame, Richard | 13 |
| Hummer, Christopher | 13 |
| Kennedy, Michael | 10 |
| Abke, Jeff | 10 |
| Freimark, Tom | 10 |
| Lenkay, Mike | 6 |